
The daw war is over.
Midi jitter on external midi, sequencing synths and drums in real time from the computer. This is a big deal to those of us who like to sequence live and mix analog for better sound quality and tight notation. Logic 8 is the winner. Logic 8 with amt8 on osx is 1ms of midi jitter! this is as tight as notator on the atari st, which to this date held the record for tight midi on a computer. now logic 8 ties this record! KUDOS TO YOU APPLE AND EMAGIC! YOU HAVE WON THE MIDI WAR. AMT8 interface was used in my test. I triggered a high hat on my dr 880 drum machine, recorded it in, wrote down all the peak transients and subtracted the differences. yup 1 ms of jitter! so drums and bass lines can finally sound tight in real time thanks to apple and logic 8. I am so happy. i bought this software. logic 8 express! it has answered all my midi prayers! finally a daw that does it all, sounds great, and is feature laden. beats out all daws now. easily the king! i bet removing the dongle had a big impact of the midi timing. i cannot thank you enough, this has been a huge hassle for me over the last 10 years. i have pulled out hair, gone insane, gotten banned off the steinberg forums, and turned many against me because of this. its over. when i tested logic 7 with the amt8, i got 3 ms of jitter on osx. so logic 8 is even better!
More on logic 8 instrument plug ins: Well i hve had time to go through and play with the instrument plug ins that logic express 8 comes with. WOW. the sample libraries that come with the exs24 are worth it! wow, great analog samples. juptier 8 and strings, choir is good too. The FM synth is ok, the VA mono and poly are ok nothing that great but better than the crap cubase comes with for sure, and all of it is useable to make good sounding music. But ultra beat is the thing that blows me away the most. great drum kits covering a lot of groun in electro. very nice. tight, fat, big and punchy. very nice. doesn’t make me regret selling my jomox for one second. This more than makes up for that. I cannot beleive all the stuff this thing has for 200 dollars! this gives you a complete sound library to make several lps with no hardware at all. It’s simply amazing to me.. The sound sets are nice in all reguards with all the plug ins. very impressed.
I all most forgot. Midi recording. you know that oh so important thing, recording your keyboard performances. This never worked right on any daw either. When i would do like piano rolls that cascade sometimes i would do 64th or 32nd notes really fast, and cubase would choke and never record it right, never play it back right, never sound like what i played in. I’ve had people watch me play, and then listen to the play back, and the people watching me would say “that isn’t what yo uplayed” all daws except logic were flawed big time. and when in loop mode cubase was bonkers and would never put the 1st beat in the right place. Logic is the only daw that has ever played back what i played in correctly and exactly. This is a huge deal to me. and in the past 10 years something that has killed my inspiration using cubase and sonar. crappy midi recording. With logic that is a thing of the past. Midi is done correctly. Many people think they suck at playing keybaords, but i bet if they tried logic, they would be suprised to find it was their computer software that was not recording them and scanning the midi correctly.. to me this is unforgiveable, perverting performances. thanks cubase, thanks sonar. no thanks. logic does it right thankfully..
PC MIDI: cubase sx with many interfaces including the midex8 on 4 different pcs i tested all were from 13 to 20 ms of midi jitter. Saw studio was 7 ms of midi jitter. Sonar 6 was 14 ms of midi jitter. Logic 5.5.1 with amt on xp(which was never stable) was 3ms of jitter but completely un usable because midi would just stop working, then you would have to reload logic and it would work for 5 minutes the quit again. so this is irrelevant.
Let me break down the daws for you in other ways. Saw has the best sound and worst interface with crap midi, sonar 6 has crap midi, second best sound and crap interface, cubase has crap sound and crap midi with an awesome interface. that is the pc side of things. on the Mac logic 7 had good midi, and decent sound, with an ok to decent interface. Now, logic 8 has a great interface, the best midi ever on a modern computer, and the sound quality is up there with sonar and samplitude. sonar had awesome time streching, now so does logic 8, cubase has awesome audio editing, but so does logic 8 now, 7 was no where close to cubase in audio editing, but now, its as good. finally logic 8 delivers on all fronts where all daws have failed before. LOGIC 8 express is 199! BUY IT NOW! Logic 8 studio is 499. BUY ONE OF THEM! cheaper than the competition, and way better in all regards! + NO MORE DONGLE!!!!!!! AWESOME!
Update: I have since upgraded to the full version of logic, Just get express and outboard fx, space design and delay designer are crap when compared to my kurzweil ksp8. Sculpture synth is nothing special either. So save your money and just buy express. Unless you need the sound track pro and waveburn, those are really useful, i use sound track to edit sound on my videos that i post on my blog. So i guess for that, it was worth it. The plug in instruments really don’t sound that great so the mainstage program either.